Guide
The worst model year for each popular model, by owner complaints
For each model on this site, the model year owners complained about most in its first three years on the road, and how far above that model's typical year it ran.
We count the complaints each model year drew in its first three years (for a 2019 model, those filed by the end of 2021), so every year is measured over the same stretch. Comparing a model with its own other years also takes most of the difference in sales between models out of the picture. The multiple is the worst year's count divided by the model's median year. Model years after 2023 don't have three full years yet and are left out, as are launch and final years with very few sold. A model needs at least four ranked years and at least 25 complaints in a typical year to be listed, because smaller counts swing too much; 71 models qualify.
| Model | Worst year | Complaints | Typical year | Multiple |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Most described in 2023: a cracked windshield · fewest: 2020 (9) |
2023 | 671 | 36.5 | 18.4x |
Most described in 2019: stalling · fewest: 2018 (5) |
2019 | 288 | 31.5 | 9.1x |
Most described in 2023: hesitation · fewest: 2021 (12) |
2023 | 286 | 39.5 | 7.2x |
Most described in 2022: steering rack problems · fewest: 2021 (41) |
2022 | 874 | 121.5 | 7.2x |
Most described in 2023: stalling · fewest: 2016 (13) |
2023 | 244 | 36 | 6.8x |
Most described in 2018: stalling · fewest: 2021 (29) |
2018 | 421 | 72.5 | 5.8x |
Most described in 2017: shifter errors · fewest: 2016 (17) |
2017 | 229 | 39.5 | 5.8x |
Most described in 2019: a cracked windshield · fewest: 2022 (19) |
2019 | 200 | 39 | 5.1x |
Most described in 2018: loss of power · fewest: 2021 (13) |
2018 | 220 | 43 | 5.1x |
Most described in 2016: power steering problems · fewest: 2019 (41) |
2016 | 659 | 143.5 | 4.6x |
Most described in 2019: a dead battery · fewest: 2023 (36) |
2019 | 281 | 62 | 4.5x |
Most described in 2018: shaking or vibration · fewest: 2016 (96) |
2018 | 1,152 | 257 | 4.5x |
Most described in 2016: headlight problems · fewest: 2020 (30) |
2016 | 187 | 42 | 4.5x |
Most described in 2018: jerking or harsh shifting · fewest: 2022 (34) |
2018 | 331 | 75 | 4.4x |
Most described in 2023: engine failure · fewest: 2020 (10) |
2023 | 287 | 65.5 | 4.4x |
Most described in 2020: stalling · fewest: 2022 (17) |
2020 | 165 | 38 | 4.3x |
Most described in 2018: hesitation · fewest: 2016 (13) |
2018 | 179 | 42.5 | 4.2x |
Most described in 2017: oil dilution · fewest: 2020 (116) |
2017 | 835 | 229 | 3.6x |
Most described in 2019: stalling · fewest: 2022 (90) |
2019 | 437 | 130 | 3.4x |
Most described in 2017: stalling · fewest: 2020 (55) |
2017 | 669 | 204 | 3.3x |
Most described in 2023: engine failure · fewest: 2020 (61) |
2023 | 480 | 147.5 | 3.3x |
Most described in 2023: engine failure · fewest: 2020 (12) |
2023 | 148 | 45.5 | 3.3x |
Most described in 2019: a cracked windshield · fewest: 2023 (61) |
2019 | 525 | 164 | 3.2x |
Most described in 2016: door lock problems · fewest: 2021 (27) |
2016 | 449 | 146 | 3.1x |
Most described in 2023: engine failure · fewest: 2020 (10) |
2023 | 96 | 31.5 | 3.0x |
Most described in 2023: suspension problems · fewest: 2020 (64) |
2023 | 430 | 143.5 | 3.0x |
Most described in 2019: stalling and auto start-stop problems · fewest: 2023 (22) |
2019 | 86 | 29 | 3.0x |
Most described in 2018: shifter errors · fewest: 2021 (23) |
2018 | 139 | 47 | 3.0x |
Most described in 2023: engine failure · fewest: 2016 (67) |
2023 | 285 | 98.5 | 2.9x |
Most described in 2017: engine failure · fewest: 2016 (32) |
2017 | 260 | 93 | 2.8x |
Most described in 2016: overheating or coolant loss · fewest: 2023 (13) |
2016 | 130 | 50.5 | 2.6x |
Most described in 2018: overheating or coolant loss · fewest: 2021 (85) |
2018 | 456 | 179.5 | 2.5x |
Most described in 2018: hesitation · fewest: 2017 (13) |
2018 | 176 | 70 | 2.5x |
Most described in 2022: a shattered sunroof · fewest: 2020 (13) |
2022 | 91 | 37 | 2.5x |
Most described in 2018: the check engine light, then loss of power · fewest: 2021 (13) |
2018 | 65 | 26.5 | 2.5x |
Most described in 2016: jerking or harsh shifting · fewest: 2022 (38) |
2016 | 200 | 83.5 | 2.4x |
Most described in 2022: phantom braking · fewest: 2019 (133) |
2022 | 666 | 283.5 | 2.3x |
Most described in 2020: a cracked windshield · fewest: 2023 (83) |
2020 | 720 | 311 | 2.3x |
Most described in 2019: power steering problems · fewest: 2023 (132) |
2019 | 470 | 210 | 2.2x |
Most described in 2019: jerking or harsh shifting · fewest: 2023 (15) |
2019 | 68 | 32 | 2.1x |
Most described in 2016: backup camera problems · fewest: 2023 (14) |
2016 | 68 | 33 | 2.1x |
Most described in 2019: transmission failure · fewest: 2022 (15) |
2019 | 72 | 35 | 2.1x |
Most described in 2023: headlight problems · fewest: 2020 (30) |
2023 | 101 | 50 | 2.0x |
Most described in 2019: stalling · fewest: 2022 (21) |
2019 | 614 | 306 | 2.0x |
Most described in 2021: stalling · fewest: 2020 (11) |
2021 | 211 | 108 | 2.0x |
Most described in 2019: the check engine light, then jerking or harsh shifting · fewest: 2018 (115) |
2019 | 338 | 175.5 | 1.9x |
Most described in 2021: jerking or harsh shifting · fewest: 2019 (27) |
2021 | 85 | 45 | 1.9x |
Most described in 2021: unintended acceleration · fewest: 2020 (17) |
2021 | 97 | 52.5 | 1.8x |
Most described in 2020: gauge cluster failures · fewest: 2023 (42) |
2020 | 215 | 116.5 | 1.8x |
Most described in 2018: the check engine light, then loss of power · fewest: 2017 (31) |
2018 | 146 | 80 | 1.8x |
Most described in 2017: excessive oil consumption · fewest: 2019 (30) |
2017 | 132 | 72.5 | 1.8x |
Most described in 2018: the airbag warning light · fewest: 2022 (12) |
2018 | 110 | 63 | 1.7x |
Most described in 2019: the check engine light, then loss of power · fewest: 2021 (7) |
2019 | 56 | 32.5 | 1.7x |
Most described in 2023: shaking or vibration · fewest: 2022 (159) |
2023 | 318 | 188.5 | 1.7x |
Most described in 2020: infotainment failures · fewest: 2018 (50) |
2020 | 206 | 122.5 | 1.7x |
Most described in 2023: the check engine light, then phantom braking · fewest: 2020 (20) |
2023 | 105 | 65.5 | 1.6x |
Most described in 2020: stalling · fewest: 2018 (16) |
2020 | 86 | 55 | 1.6x |
Most described in 2017: stalling · fewest: 2019 (59) |
2017 | 154 | 101 | 1.5x |
Most described in 2021: a cracked windshield and rust or corrosion · fewest: 2022 (14) |
2021 | 46 | 30.5 | 1.5x |
Most described in 2019: shaking or vibration · fewest: 2017 (20) |
2019 | 38 | 25.5 | 1.5x |
Most described in 2018: headlight problems · fewest: 2020 (11) |
2018 | 59 | 41.5 | 1.4x |
Most described in 2019: stalling · fewest: 2021 (10) |
2019 | 43 | 31.5 | 1.4x |
Most described in 2017: overheating or coolant loss · fewest: 2019 (71) |
2017 | 221 | 165 | 1.3x |
Most described in 2019: transmission failure · fewest: 2023 (14) |
2019 | 85 | 63.5 | 1.3x |
Most described in 2019: transmission failure · fewest: 2016 (49) |
2019 | 152 | 114 | 1.3x |
Most described in 2023: phantom braking · fewest: 2020 (148) |
2023 | 976 | 744.5 | 1.3x |
Most described in 2020: a cracked windshield · fewest: 2021 (140) |
2020 | 246 | 190 | 1.3x |
Most described in 2018: jerking or harsh shifting · fewest: 2019 (161) |
2018 | 501 | 388 | 1.3x |
Most described in 2016: excessive oil consumption and engine failure · fewest: 2020 (25) |
2016 | 53 | 44 | 1.2x |
Most described in 2021: loss of power · fewest: 2020 (29) |
2021 | 132 | 116 | 1.1x |
Most described in 2016: airbags not deploying · fewest: 2021 (49) |
2016 | 88 | 82 | 1.1x |
Reading the table
- A high multiple shows where owners reported trouble. It doesn't prove a defect: complaints are unverified reports, and a particular car from a bad year can be perfectly sound.
- Sales still matter within a model. A year that sold unusually well or badly will look higher or lower than its real rate.
- The model pages go deeper. Each model's best and worst years page ranks every year, and each year's recalls and problems page lists the problems owners describe and the areas NHTSA files complaints under.
- Look up the specific car too. Run any used car's VIN through NHTSA's lookup before you buy. Here's how.
Sources and method
- NHTSA owner complaint file (FLAT_CMPL).
- Method: model year Y counts complaints filed by the end of Y+2.
Written with AI tools from the site's EPA and NHTSA data and reviewed by the editor. How we build these pages. Spotted an error? Tell us.